Blog post —
Understanding BRIZO’s Performance Ratio
Lesson 2: Lessons from the sea
For the second lesson in our Lessons from the Sea series for LinkedIn, we spoke with Nathan Roosloot, PhD and Research Scientist at the Institute for Energy Technology (IFE), who leads the ENHANCING BRIZO Innovation Project for the Industrial Sector funded by the Research Council of Norway.
The ENHANCING BRIZO project builds on operational data from the BRIZO pilot in Risør, Norway, which has now been in operation for three years. Together with IFE, the project investigates the performance of our floating solar technology, BRIZO, meaning the factors influencing energy production and system losses. This is mainly done through analysis of data recorded on the pilot, including weather conditions and power production, combined with on-site measurement campaigns and modelling efforts. The aim is to estimate the energy yield of the BRIZO system at any deployment location in the world, also for large-scale deployments.
In this video interview, Nathan explains the findings regarding BRIZO’s performance ratio of 0.83 for tropical climates:
For even more in-depth answers, read the full interview with Nathan below:
What is Performance Ratio?
Performance Ratio is a key measure of how well a solar system performs. Below Nathan explains what it is and why it is so useful:
“The performance ratio, also called the PR, is the ratio between actual and theoretical electricity production of a solar system over a certain period. Here, the theoretical production is based on the size of the solar system and real weather conditions. Using the performance ratio gives more insight into how well a solar system performs than if we would only look at total electricity generation. This is because the performance ratio takes into consideration if it is a sunny day or a cloudy day. After all, it is not the system’s fault that it is not generating electricity when the sun is not shining!
The value of the performance ratio gives insight into how well the system performs: if the ratio is 1, actual production is the same as theoretical production. A PR value that is lower than 1 indicates that production is lower than what is theoretically possible, meaning that somewhere between sunlight hitting the panel and electricity being fed into the grid, more energy was lost than expected. There can be many pathways in which energy is lost. For example, if modules are shaded or soiled, not all incident light reaches the solar cells where it is turned into electricity. Other losses include conversion of electricity from direct to alternating current, system downtime or degradation, etcetera. Commercial systems will always have certain losses, and the performance ratio is therefore usually lower than 1.”
How does BRIZO compare?
So how does BRIZO measure up? Nathan compares the pilot's results with well-performing land-based and other floating solar systems:
“Based on analysis of measured production and weather data over a 13-month period at the Brizo pilot in Risør, we determined the PR to be equal to 0.81. This value corresponds with the PR of well-functioning PV systems on land. There is much less literature available on the performance of floating PV systems, but the values that have been published are roughly between 0.7-0.9. This shows that BRIZO’s performance is on par with that of other commercial PV systems, whether on water or on land. This shows that the Brizo system does not encounter significantly higher loss factors than other commercial systems, and provides confidence that the system will function well in other environments also.”
From Norway to warmer climates
The pilot is located in Norway, so what can its results tell us about warmer climates? Nathan explains what we can learn from Risør and what is important to keep in mind.
“The performance ratio normalizes for irradiance, and we additionally calculated a performance ratio that also corrects for the operating temperature. This temperature corrected PR also had a value of 0.81. As a result, the higher temperatures and more sunlight that are expected in tropical regions compared to Norway are not expected to change the temperature corrected PR directly. However, the PR can be affected by other changes in climate conditions. For example, the modules in Risør were covered in snow for part of the winter, lowering the PR in periods with sunlight. Furthermore, the low angle of the sun in the winter in Norway leads to higher reflection losses. Such effects will be smaller or entirely absent in tropical climates, and we therefore excluded some of the winter months from the data to find a PR value that is more representative for non-Nordic climates. This resulted in a PR value of 0.83.
While there thus exist weather conditions in Norway that affect the PR differently than in the tropics, the opposite can be true also. For example, hot and humid air in tropical regions can degrade the PV modules faster than they would in Norway, and soiling can be different too. Luckily, there are a lot of studies on performance and reliability of land-based solar systems in the tropics that help estimate how performance would be affected by changing environment, and several of the models developed in this project can be used to extrapolate to other operating conditions. But to precisely quantify how the system performs in the tropics, analysis on an actual system deployed in such a climate would of course be best.
When extrapolating learnings from the Brizo pilot to other deployment locations, it is not only important to consider the climate zone of deployment, but also the type of water body the system is deployed in. For example, higher waves can impact both performance and long-term reliability.”
Looking beyond Performance Ratio
Performance Ratio is only one piece of the puzzle. Nathan shares what else the team is investigating and why it matters.
“Now that we have quantified the performance ratio of Brizo, we are carrying out more detailed investigations into the most important factors that have caused energy loss. We here focus on three factors which are expected to be different from land-based solar systems. Firstly, we look at operating temperatures of the modules. More specifically, we are quantifying how well the PV modules in the Brizo system exchange heat with their environment, as better exchange can lead to lower operating temperatures, which in turn boost energy production. Secondly, we look at wave-induced losses. As the modules move due to waves, their orientation towards the sun changes, affecting the amount of light that reaches the cells, and thereby the current generated by these modules. As a result, the current of a group of modules connected in series becomes limited by the worst-performing module, causing a performance loss. And lastly, we look at how soiling affects production. High activity of birds has been reported around several floating PV systems, and bird droppings can cause more heavy soiling than commonly encountered on land. Quantifying these three losses, and identifying the best mitigation strategies, is therefore important.
The high-quality measurement data that is recorded on the Brizo pilot in Risør allows us to quantify each of these three factors with high confidence, providing a better understanding in how each of these affect performance, how resulting losses can be minimized, and how they can be predicted for other systems. “