Blog post -

Blockchain and initial coin offerings (ICOs)

Introduction

As subsets of financial markets, capital markets are integral parts in producing monetary output in economies globally, through which debt or equity-backed securities are bought and sold. The blockchain concept has generated a huge amount of interest within capital markets. Blockchain offers a new approach to data management and sharing that is being proposed as a solution to many of the inefficiencies afflicting the industry. The idea is to have a new architecture, where all capital market participants work from common datasets, in near real-time, and where supporting operations are either streamlined or made redundant.

ICOs

A new method of capital raising called the Initial Coin Offering has exploded this year. It is a process where tech start-ups, mainly from inside the digital-currency sector, create a new virtual coin or token and offer it for public sale. It lies somewhere between a traditional initial public offering (IPO) and investment-based crowdfunding. However, the term ICO is somewhat misleading: these flotations are quite different from the similar-sounding IPOs (when companies list on a stock exchange). For example, whereas investors in shares receive ownership rights and dividends, those who put their money in ICOs get crypto-currency, or tokens issued on a blockchain. They are meant to serve as the currency for the project they finance: to pay for storage space on blockchain data storage network - Filecoin for example (in October 2017 Filecoin has officially finalised its ICO, raising more than $257 million over one month of activity). They can also be traded by speculators; investors hope that successful projects will cause tokens' value to rise. This new method of financing is turning the traditional venture capital model on its head, because then, theoretically, companies do not need venture capitalists.

Another big difference between IPOs and ICOs is that most ICOs are currently unregulated. Instead of providing an audited prospectus, for instance, issuers just publish a "white paper" which often describes the project's aspirations in glowing terms. In fact, regulators worldwide are getting extremely worried on how ICOs are being marketed. For example, in September 2017, the SEC charged a businessman and two of his companies for defrauding investors in an alleged ICO scheme. The SEC said it charged the parties with selling unregistered cryptocurrency securities reputedly backed by investments in real estate and diamonds, when it found no such investments had taken place.

It is expected that in the short-term, ICOs will continue to impact what investors are thinking about and effect how relatively small amounts of capital are allocated. In the medium-term, the number and size of crypto-funds will grow and a few decentralised protocols of tremendous value that deliver actual value to end users (not just speculators) may emerge.

This is a challenging, but at the same time, very exciting area to be in. In fact, an investment in ICOs comes with a lot of caution. It opens up the way to evaluate companies. For example, it is extremely important that all the due diligence aspects are done (like what is done in start-ups). One also has to look at the resilience of the crypto-sale that the company is planning. Thirdly, it is vital to look at the level of transparency that these companies are giving to investors. Finally, it is extremely important to look at the business model and how it ties into the token that the company is issuing. This area is a very important one, and sometimes it gets disconnected from the actual operations of the business.

ESMA's Opinion on ICOs

On the 13th of November 2017, ESMA issued two warnings concerning ICOs (one addressed to investors and another to firms involved in ICOs). ESMA announced that ICOs are extremely risky and highly speculative investment vehicles. Furthermore, it also issued a warning to those firms involved in ICOs that they should give careful consideration as to whether the ICO qualifies as a financial instrument. ESMA pointed out that if the activities constitute regulated activities, then the firms involved in the project need to comply with the relevant legislation, including for example:

  • the Prospectus Directive;
  • the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID);
  • the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD); and
  • the Fourth Anti-Money Laundering Directive.

Topics

  • Consulting

Categories

  • esma
  • initial coin offering
  • ico
  • virtual currencies
  • fintech
  • cryptocurrencies
  • crypto
  • blockchain

Related content

  • Malta’s gaming industry to become simpler and safer

    ​On May 10, 2018, a new gaming act was approved by the Maltese parliament. The newly passed piece of legislation provides for a more strict, yet less bureaucratic, supervision of the gambling companies by the MGA – the official regulator – with a view to simplifying the procedures and combatting illegal activities, namely money laundering and terrorist financing.

  • Blockchain and payment services

    The distributed ledger makes it possible to connect all the parties in a financial​ trade in real time for faster processing of a payment – all while maintaining an audit trail. As such, it is virtually impossible to change or control the data, since processing is distributed over the network. This is vital in preventing fraud or a security breach.

  • Blockchain and investment services

    ​Bloc​kchain technology has transformed from a popular buzzword to a technology that is in the process of revamping a wide range of operational and business processes within the financial s​ervice industry. A segment of the financial industry that could benefit greatly from the implementation of the distributed ledger technology is the invest​ment services sector.

  • Blockchain and banking

    ​Some industry experts believe that implementing blockchain technology in the banking sector is poised to solve multiple challenges facing such industry by facilitating faster, secure, and more transparent transactions. However, ​blockchain presents a double-edge sword for banks.

  • The impact of blockchain on the financial services sector

    ​Blockchain​ technology is transforming the financial services industry and creating opportunities for both new and established players. Blockchain's ability to provide a new form of distributed database or ledger could be applied across a broad range of applications in financial services.

  • Proposed regulatory framework for virtual currencies and DLT

    The Maltese regulator is currently working on three draft bills that shall set out a regulatory framework for the certification of Distributed Ledger Technology Platforms, ICOs, Virt​ual Currencies, Virtual Currency Exchanges and related service providers.

  • Malta's blockchain strategy

    Malta's strategy has the single and focused purpose of making Malta one of the first countries in the world to embrace blockchain and jump on the bandwagon of the new economy. The plan is for Malta to pioneer a change at EU level, with the goal of dubbing the EU as the 'Bitcoin continent'.

  • Malta’s VFA Framework – What Next?

    During 2018, the VFA Framework was implemented in Maltese Law. Since then, various other jurisdictions have taken initiatives to implement their own VFA framework. Moreover, movements in the European Union to harmonise this industry have also been anticipated.