Skip to main content

HMRC secures tenth win against NT Advisors – protecting more than £900 million

Press Release   •   Sep 26, 2016 13:02 BST

HMRC has won its tenth successive case against tax avoidance schemes promoted by NT Advisors.

This means that HMRC’s court successes against the promoter have now protected £916 million in tax. Previous victories include the defeat of the controversial Working Wheels scheme, where participants claimed to be second-hand car dealers.

The Court of Appeal has ruled that NT Advisors’ latest scheme consists of a series of circular payments designed purely to generate tax deductions with no genuine commercial purpose. No tax relief is therefore due.

The latest ruling covers 304 users and will protect £143 million for the UK.

Jennie Granger, HMRC’s Director General of Enforcement and Compliance, said:

“HMRC has a 100% success record against NT Advisors in the courts. If you are currently using one of their schemes, or any other avoidance scheme, we will help you get out if you get in touch with us.”

HMRC’s dedicated helpline for people who have engaged in tax avoidance is 03000 530 435. Further information can also be found at

In addition to the ten litigation wins, HMRC also successfully defended a Judicial Review brought by NT Advisors which challenged the issue of Schedule 36 notices to obtain information on avoidance schemes.

HMRC has collected £3 billion from users of tax avoidance schemes in the last two years under its “accelerated payments” programme, which collects disputed tax up front. It is also consulting on tough new penalties for accountants, tax planners and advisers who provide advice on how to avoid tax.

Notes to Editors:

1.The Upper Tribunal ruling in Andrew Chappell versus The Commissioners for HM Revenue and Customs can be found at

2.This complex scheme devised by NT Advisors used a series of circular and self-cancelling transactions involving alleged overseas securities. These purported to create substantial tax deductions where in reality no economic loss had been suffered.

3.The £916 million is from:

‘Chappell’, covering 304 users, protecting £143 million.

‘SG Repo’, ‘Working Wheels’ and ‘Stony Heating’, involving just over 1,000 users, protecting £630 million.

A first-tier tribunal ruling against ‘Blue box’ involving 70 users and £48 million. NT Advisors are continuing litigation.

‘Romangate’ covering 359 users, protecting £95 million.

4.Follow HMRC Press Office on Twitter @HMRCpressoffice

  1. Issued by HM Revenue & Customs Press Office

HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) is the UK’s tax authority.

HMRC is responsible for making sure that the money is available to fund the UK’s public services and for helping families and individuals with targeted financial support.