Press release -

Press release: NGOs urge EP to push for full implementation of the CFP

Brussels 16 March 2022: Ahead of the European Parliament’s public hearing on the implementation and future perspectives of the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) tomorrow, NGOs are calling on EU institutions and Member States to better follow and enforce the rules of the policy, rather than considering any reform at this stage.

Vera Coelho, Senior Director of Advocacy at Oceana in Europe, said “The Common Fisheries Policy is fit for purpose – but Member States and EU institutions fail to properly implement it. Engaging in a new reform would distract from taking real action to deliver on the CFP’s commitments to end overfishing, manage fisheries according to ecosystem limits and promote socio-economic benefits. In the current ecological crises and while severe overfishing continues, we have no time for such distractions.”

While it has been in force since 2014, poor implementation of the CFP by the EU and its member countries is preventing its objectives for sustainable fisheries in Europe from being achieved. For example, 43% of fish stocks in the North-East Atlantic and 83% of those in the Mediterranean are still subject to overfishing1.

NGOs are calling for concrete solutions to urgently address the challenges of implementing the CFP. For example, the EU Council, national governments and fishers must work together and follow scientific advice to end overfishing, transition fairly (in terms of socio-economics) to low-impact fisheries to mitigate negative impacts on ecosystems (e.g. bycatch of endangered species), and include a climate component in fisheries management (e.g. lessen the impact of the fishing sector on global greenhouse gas emissions).

Rebecca Hubbard, Programme Director of Our Fish said “While the EU’s fisheries legislation does not mention climate change, it calls for environmental impacts of fishing to be minimised, which clearly includes climate impacts, of which the EU fishing fleet has many. So at this point, we need more delivery of already-made good laws from EU Member States and MEPs, and less blah blah about potential improvements.”

Before considering any reform of the CFP, NGOs state that the European Commission and EU Member States should use the tools already available in the policy and in other legal instruments to properly implement and enforce its rules. The Commission, for example, should use its power to initiate legislative and political action, including legal sanctions against countries who do not abide by the rules.

Antonia Leroy, Head of Ocean Policy at WWF European Policy Office added: “It would be premature to consider the CFP’s objectives as inadequate when some of these objectives, and certain key tools to achieve them, remain generally overlooked. For instance, it is time to dedicate specific quotas to fishers striving to minimise their impact on marine ecosystems, while also making sure that they enjoy a fair standard of living, as called for by the CFP.”

Further information:
This public hearing will feed into an own-initiative report, led by MEP Gabriel Mato on behalf of the European Parliament (EP), and will express the EP’s position on the CFP and its future. In the meantime, the European Commission is preparing a separate report on the functioning of the CFP, due by the end of December, which will determine the future of the policy.

In addition to its legislative role, the European Parliament is supposed to ensure democratic accountability regarding the protection of the marine environment. Crucially, the EP should scrutinise the progress made in ending overfishing and the situation of fish stocks, as well as the functioning of the fisheries policy as a whole2.

The European Commission is obliged to regularly report to the EP on, for example, fish stock recovery areas and adjustment and management of EU fleets’ fishing capacity3. Further, the Parliament has the power to scrutinise delegated (non-legislative) acts proposed by the Commission, for example by adopting fisheries management for marine protected areas4.

The Common Fisheries Policy is a set of rules for managing European fishing fleets and conserving fish stocks. It was reformed in 2013 to put the EU on track to meet its sustainability goals with ambitious objectives and concrete timelines. In the last decade, this led to a reduction in the overfishing rate of some species and an increase in the net profitability of the EU fleet (from being only marginally profitable in 2008).

However, the EU failed to meet its legal commitment in the CFP to end overfishing for all fish populations by 2020 despite repeated warnings by NGOs and scientific reports confirming the trajectory was off course5.

Contact:

Dave Walsh, Our Fish Communications Advisor, press@our.fish, +34 691 826 764

End notes:

  1. EC report of June 2021: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_2875
  2. CFP articles 49-50
  3. CFP articles 8 & 22
  4. CFP article 11
  5. Scientific, Technical and Economic Committee for Fisheries, “Monitoring the performance of the Common Fisheries Policy” (2021), https://bit.ly/3enUvJ5

Press briefing:

A video recording of the media briefing: “Future Perspectives of the Common Fisheries Policy” is available here.

Related links

Topics

  • Agriculture, fishing

Categories

  • cfp
  • eu
  • overfishing
  • pech
  • eu-council
  • pech committee
  • return of the cod
  • fisheries
  • common fisheries policy
  • eu commission

www.fishsec.org FishSec (Fiskesekretariatet) is an independent non-partisan not for profit organization that works for the conservation and restoration of marine ecosystem services, with a focus on fishing. The goal is well-managed seas with rich biodiversity and thriving fish stocks. FishSec is active on the EU-level and in the Baltic Sea region and advocates for fishing that is within the limits of what the marine ecosystem can handle.

Related content

  • Rescue plan for Baltic cod shall be based on the latest research

    FishSec is starting a two-year project to aid the recovery of the collapsed cod stock in the Baltic Sea. As part of the Return of the Cod project, which is part-funded by the Postcode Foundation, FishSec will develop proposals for a rescue plan for Baltic cod and analyze the potential socio-economic effects of proposed measures.

  • EU Must Respond to Baltic Sea Ecosystem and Fisheries Crash With Urgent, Radical Measures

    Responding to today's publication of annual scientific advice for 2022 EU fishing limits for the Baltic Sea by ICES (International Council for the Exploration of the Sea) [1], a group of non-governmental organisations is demanding that the European Commission follow the scientific advice and calls for an immediate transition to ecosystem-based, climate-smart, low-impact fishing.

  • Report: Fisheries closures fail to protect critically endangered eel

    European eel has been in decline for decades and is on the IUCN and EU Red lists as Critically Endangered. Despite this, European eel remains the target of both commercial and recreational fishing in most EU Member States. EU measures for its recovery agreed in 2017 has not yet led to any improvements.

  • NGOs welcome increased precaution in Commission’s proposal for Baltic Sea fishing opportunities in 2023

    Brussels 25 August 2022: On the 23rd of August the European Commission released its proposal for Baltic Sea fishing opportunities for 2023. Over and all, the Commission applied a precautionary stance when setting the recommendations for Total Allowable Catches (TACs) for next year which is to be commended. Many fish populations in the Baltic Sea are in a bad state with overfishing as one of the ma

  • Record catch of ghost fishing gear on the Swedish West coast

    Frightening, yet hopeful, news from Sotenäs on the Swedish W coast. Last week they noted a record catch in their ghost fishing gear retrieving project, in one day 34 lost lobster tins were retrieved. Since 2017 a total of 950 lobster tins have been found.

  • Overfishing continues in EU waters

    After lengthy negotiations, EU fisheries ministers reached an agreement on fishing opportunities in 2022 on Tuesday morning, including 23 catch limits for fish populations in the North-East Atlantic exclusively managed by the EU, as well as fishing effort restrictions for Mediterranean waters. The result: around 35 % of catch limits will allow continued overfishing, including stocks of southern ha

  • The collapse of Baltic cod

    A Baltic catch in 1987. The photo above was taken in March 1987 during a three week research expedition in the Baltic, carried out by the Danish research vessel R/V DANA. One of the researchers on board was Ph.D. Eero Aro – the man you see in the photo hugging a 22 kg large female cod caught in the Southern part of the Baltic in the Polish fishing grounds Slupsk Furrow.

  • Fisheries ministers continue overfishing in breach of EU law

    EU Common Fisheries Policy obligates member states to achieve maximum sustainable yield “by 2020 at the latest”. Still, December 17, EU fisheries ministers decided to set around one third of the Atlantic fishing quotas for 2021 managed exclusively by the EU above the sustainable limits advised by scientists. And the Mediterranean will remain the most overfished sea in the world.

  • “The Herring stock in the Baltic Proper is being fished too hard”

    Researchers at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, SLU, today suggest that “restrictions on trawling close to the coast could be a good measure”, to protect local spawning stocks of herring. They also warn that “If we want fish stocks to have a healthy size structure, both management and research need to focus on developing and changing the management objectives that govern decisions"

  • Joint NGO recommendations on Baltic Sea fishing opportunities 2023

    FishSec together with a large number of Baltic wide NGOs have launched a joint position on the fishing opportunities in the Baltic Sea for the year 2023, following the release of the ICES advice in late May. The position calls for better advice on ecosystem-based management options, as well as the inclusion of multi-species interactions, sub-populations and age-and size distribution in the scienti

  • Report: New study on dramatic decline of cod in the Baltic Sea

    Stockholm, March 24 2022; The Eastern Baltic cod population used to be one of the largest cod populations in the Atlantic. Today, decades of overexploitation paired with eutrophication and habitat degradation have led to a dramatic decline in the two main populations (Eastern and Western) of Baltic cod. But it is not too late for the species to recover. If decisive action is taken to protect the f

  • EU Member States share concern for eel population in dire straits

    Speaking to the EU Fisheries Council, Commissioner Sinkevičius was clear that “status quo is not an option” for the management of European eel, considering the critical state of the eel population and the zero catch advice. But EU Member States have few suggestions for how to save the eel and improve conservation efforts.