Press release -

Report: Fisheries closures fail to protect critically endangered eel

The European eel has been in decline for decades and is on the IUCN Red list as Critically Endangered. Despite this, a wide-spread commercial and recreational fishery is allowed to continue in the EU. In 2017, a Joint Declaration to aid its recovery was adopted, including national three-month fishing closures to protect eel migration. Our report shows that many Member States are more likely to protect their fishing sector than the eels.

The European eel has been in decline for decades and is on the IUCN Red list as Critically Endangered. Despite this, a wide-spread commercial and recreational fishery is allowed to continue in the EU. In 2017, a Joint Declaration to aid its recovery was adopted, including national three-month fishing closures to protect eel migration. Our report shows that many Member States are more likely to protect their fishing sector than the eels.Despite decades of decline, the critically endangered European eel is still the target of both commercial and recreational fishing in most EU Member States. In 2017, the Commission proposed to close all fishing for eel longer than 12 cm in EU waters, in line with scientific advice. The EU Member States rejected this proposal. Instead, the three-month closures were part of a political compromise agreement – a Joint Declaration for eel recovery.

Since the last December Council, coastal EU Member States have yet again decided on three months during which all eel fisheries will be closed in the coming fishing season. The plans for all of the closures in 2021/2022 should now have been reported to the European Commission.

In our new report, FishSec has assessed whether the current national eel fishing closures – for the 2020/2021 fishing season – complied with the legal requirements, as well as the intent to protect eel migration. Sadly, we found that while the majority of the coastal EU Member States are in compliance with the legal requirements of closing their eel fisheries for three consecutive months, only a few countries fulfil the intent to protect the mature silver eels that are on their way to the Sargasso Sea to reproduce.

— The closures were intended to protect eels during their most vulnerable life stages by reducing the fishing effort during migration, but have not stopped several countries from actually increasing their catches since they were first implemented in 2018, says Elena Tamarit Castro, co-author of the report. In many countries there is little or no overlap with the main migration period, and the targeting of mature individuals on their way to the spawning grounds after spending 10–20 years in European waters continues.

FishSec also discovered that several countries, including Denmark, Sweden[1], Italy and the Netherlands, allow landings and/or sales to take place during the closed period, after keeping eels alive in submerged storage containers or land-based tanks, a practice that makes control and enforcement of the ban an even greater challenge.

Considering its conservation status and the recurring scientific advice from the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES) to reduce all anthropogenic mortality to as close to zero as possible[2], the continued widespread targeting of European eel is really unacceptable. The population is below any conceivable biological reference points, and continued fishing is therefore also a breach of the Common Fisheries Policy objectives, and goes against the aim of the EU Biodiversity Strategy to protect biodiversity and sensitive species.

— Even with closures perfectly aligned with peak migration, this conservation measure is less effective and more difficult to control than a full protection of this endangered species that was once so common across Europe, says Niki Sporrong, Senior Policy Office and European eel Project Manager at FishSec.

Together with several other NGOs, FishSec calls on the Commission and the EU decision-makers to at least apply the same rules to European eel as to other fisheries – that the objectives of the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) and the scientific advice are followed. The three-month ban was introduced to avoid a full closure, but has so far failed to deliver on the original intention. It is time for the Member States to rectify this and for the Commission to make sure it is implemented. If there are no improvements, the Commission must again propose a full prohibition to protect the eel.

[1]Sweden updated its legislation on 1 May 2021 to simplify control and enforcement, and landings are only allowed for up to 14 days after the start of the fishing closure

[2]The ICES advice has been more or less the same since 2000 – for 20 years.

Contacts:

Niki Sporrong, Senior Policy Officer and European eel Project Manager, niki.sporrong@fishsec.org, +46 70 853 12 25

Jan Isakson, Director, jan.isakson@fishsec.org, +46 70 608 74 83

Related links

Topics

  • Agriculture, fishing

Categories

  • fisheries
  • common fisheries policy
  • overfishing
  • endangered
  • red list
  • eel
  • baltic
  • baltic sea
  • cfp
  • iucn
  • eu
  • eu commission
  • eu-council
  • european eel
  • fiske
  • freshwater fish
  • danish fisheries

www.fishsec.org FishSec (Fiskesekretariatet) is an independent non-partisan not for profit organization that works for the conservation and restoration of marine ecosystem services, with a focus on fishing. The goal is well-managed seas with rich biodiversity and thriving fish stocks. FishSec is active on the EU-level and in the Baltic Sea region and advocates for fishing that is within the limits of what the marine ecosystem can handle.

Related content

  • Widespread public support for further measures to protect eel – NGOs hand over petition to Commissioner Sinkevičius

    On 7 September, a group of NGOs from the informal Eel Alliance is meeting with Commissioner Sinkevičius to hand over the Power to the Eel petition – a call for action to protect the critically endangered European eel. With over 40,000 signatures from across the EU, it shows that there is widespread public support for stronger measures to aid its recovery. A new campaign to stop fishing and farming

  • Press release: NGOs urge EP to push for full implementation of the CFP

    Brussels 16 March 2022: Ahead of the European Parliament’s public hearing on the implementation and future perspectives of the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) tomorrow, NGOs are calling on EU institutions and Member States to better follow and enforce the rules of the policy, rather than considering any reform at this stage.
    Vera Coelho, Senior Director of Advocacy at Oceana in Europe, said “The

  • Danish fishers and conservationists jointly propose marine reserves

    After months of negotiations, the Danish Society for Nature Conservation, DN, and the Danish Fishermen Producer Organisation, DFPO, present a historical proposal for ensuring a significant protection of the Danish sea. The proposal will ensure 10 percent untouched sea - no take Marine Protected Areas - in the North Sea, the Skagerrak, and the Baltic Sea, and is now handed over to the government.

  • More fish in Swedish lakes, marine populations in decline

    Catches of marine fish species such as herring, saithe and nephrops should be reduced, and cod in the Kattegat and the eastern Baltic Sea should not be fished at all. But several freshwater fish species are increasing in numbers, according to a report from Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, SLU.

  • Roll-over of three month fishing closures for eel

    At the Fisheries Council last week, many big issues competed for attention and not much was heard about the Critically Endangered European eel. The Council did, however, agree on a roll-over of the current provisions for a three-month closure of all eel fisheries.

  • Fisheries ministers continue overfishing in breach of EU law

    EU Common Fisheries Policy obligates member states to achieve maximum sustainable yield “by 2020 at the latest”. Still, December 17, EU fisheries ministers decided to set around one third of the Atlantic fishing quotas for 2021 managed exclusively by the EU above the sustainable limits advised by scientists. And the Mediterranean will remain the most overfished sea in the world.

  • Baltic Sea Advisory Council calls for the creation of a taskforce to work on the recovery of the collapsed eastern Baltic cod

    The Baltic Sea Advisory Council (BSAC), a publicly funded body providing advice on fisheries to the European Commission, has made a statement concerning the need for responsible fisheries management and the negative situation for eastern Baltic cod. The cod fishery has been closed since July 2019 and due to slow population recovery will likely remain so for several years to come.

  • Scientific evaluation: No overall progress on EU eel recovery targets

    Today, the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea, ICES, published the results of its evaluation of the national progress reports on implementation of their Eel Management Plans. It shows that attainment of the EU recovery objective for the critically endangered European eel is lower today than in 2012. Reported mortality has decreased in most management areas, but has increased in o

  • EU Member States share concern for eel population in dire straits

    Speaking to the EU Fisheries Council, Commissioner Sinkevičius was clear that “status quo is not an option” for the management of European eel, considering the critical state of the eel population and the zero catch advice. But EU Member States have few suggestions for how to save the eel and improve conservation efforts.