News -
Lipedema Vs Lymphedema Vs Cellulite: How To Spot The Difference & The Psychological Impact After Liposuction
Lipedema, lymphedema, and cellulite are distinct medical and skin conditions, although they can appear quite similar, often presenting as skin dimpling and uneven, bumpy skin texture.
Adding to the confusion are the similar conditions that sound the same: "lipedema" and "lymphedema." That plus 15 to 17 percent of patients with lymphedema ALSO have lipedema, making distinguishing between these two even more challenging [3].
Recognising the symptoms of lipedema, lymphedema, and cellulite is the first step toward obtaining an accurate diagnosis to receive the appropriate treatment.
What lipedema, lymphedema and cellulite look like, including their stages, types and grades
Lipedema stages and types
According to Herbst KL et. al,
- Lipedema Stage 1: The skin looks smooth but feels pebbly underneath due to loose connective tissue.
- Lipedema Stage 2: There is more lipedema tissue, causing skin dimpling and larger nodules. The arms may show sagging tissue and a noticeable cuff around the wrists.
- Lipedema Stage 3: The lipedema tissue is thicker with many large nodules and hanging lobes of tissue. Patients (e) and (f) have lipedema, obesity and lipo-lymphedema.
Note: A tissue cuff around the ankles or wrists can appear in all stages.
Types I to V describe the locations of lipedema tissue.
- Type I Lipedema: Lipedema tissue around the hips and buttocks
- Type II Lipedema: From just under the belly to the knees
- Type III Lipedema: From just under the belly to the ankles
- Type IV Lipedema: In the arms
- Type V Lipedema: In the lower legs (not shown)
Lymphedema Grades & Stages
Stage 1 lymphedema: Swelling occurs during the day but subsides overnight when lying flat. The affected area may indent when pressed but may return to normal by morning. Treatment isn't usually needed.
Stage 2 lymphedema: Swelling does not go away overnight and requires management. The tissue becomes soft and bouncy rather than indented when pressed. This stage shows signs of hardening in the limbs.
Stage 3 lymphedema: Swelling is permanent, and the affected area becomes larger and harder. Some people consider surgery to remove excess tissue, but it can be risky and might worsen lymphedema.
Stage 4 lymphedema: The affected limb becomes noticeably larger with bumps or lumps on the skin.
Cellulite grades
The classification of cellulite, as proposed by Nürnberger and Müller, is based on four distinct grades according to clinical presentation:
- Cellulite Grade 0: No skin dimpling under any circumstances
- Cellulite Grade 1: Dimpling when pinched
- Cellulite Grade 2: Visible skin dimpling while standing
- Cellulite Grade 3: Visible skin dimpling both when standing and lying
Differences & Similarities in Lipedema, Lymphedema & Cellulite
| Lipedema | Obesity | Fat Legs | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Definition | Painful fat disease with high output lymphatic failure | Localised subcutaneous tissue swelling | Skin dimpling and indentation of the subcutaneous fat |
| Occurrence | In females only | Males and females alike | More common in females than males |
| Causes | • Genetic • Hormones • Inflammation • Fibrosis • Fluid build-up in tissues |
• Genetic defect • Cancer Treatment • Infection • Lymphatic system injury • Disrupted lymphatic system • Health conditions |
• Hormonal fluctuations • Significant weight gain • Poor diet • Unhealthy lifestyle • Dehydration • Medical conditions • Ageing |
| Limbs affected | Both limbs affected by cuffs, including the arms and shoulders | One limb affected | In the outer and inner thighs, buttocks, abdomen |
| Symptoms | • Pain and tenderness • Symmetrical swelling • Easy bruising • Heaviness in the affected area • Unusual or sudden fatigue • Reduced range of movement • Irregular fat distribution • Skin Changes |
• Pain and tenderness • Swelling in affected area, including fingers/toes • Heaviness and tightness in the affected area • Unusual or sudden fatigue • Reduced range of movement • Infections • Skin Changes |
• No pain, no tenderness • Skin Changes |
| Skin | Tender to the touch | Thickened skin | Dimpled skin texture |
| Would a compression garment improve the appearance? | ✓ | X | X |
| Complications | ✓ | ✓ | X |
| Medical condition | ✓ | ✓ | X |
| Danger to health | • Immobility • Disability due to impaired daily activities • Orthopaedic changes |
• Immobility • Disability due to impaired daily activities • Recurring infection • Increased risk of cancer • May lead to other health or skin problems |
• Limited clothing choices |
| Diagnosis | • Physical examination • Medical history • Ultrasound |
• Physical examination • Medical history • Ultrasound • NIRF lymphatic imaging • CT scans • Lymphoscintigraphy • MRI scans |
• Visual examination • Pinch test • Lifestyle history |
| Treatment | • Manual lymphatic drainage • Exercise • Compression garment • Lipedema Surgery with Liposuction |
• Manual lymphatic drainage • Exercise • Lymphedema Surgery |
• Manual lymphatic drainage • Exercise • Weight loss programme • Cellulite Reduction with Liposuction with Fat Grafting |
Proven Improved Psychological Impact & Quality Of Life Of Patients After Liposuction and lymphedema surgery
Patients who have liposuction for lipedema mainly do it to relieve discomfort and improve their condition. After the surgery, they often experience less pain and a better quality of life [4]. Liposuction can reduce pain, bruising, and swelling and may also help reduce migraine attacks in those with lipedema [5].
Female patients who have undergone lymphedema surgery in their arms reported significant improvements in physical health, bodily pain, energy levels, social life, and mental health one year after the procedure [6]. Another study found that patients showed reduced anxiety and depression and better overall well-being after undergoing liposuction for upper extremity lymphedema [7].
Using liposuction combined with fat grafting to improve cellulite skin quality and repair tissue has also shown a high success rate with low complication rate In 126 cellulite patients — 121 (96%) women and 5 (4%) men [8].
FAQ on Lipedema, Lymphedema & Cellulite
What is the life expectancy of someone with lipedema?
Lipedema mainly affects quality of life through pain and mobility issues, but usually does not impact life expectancy.
How can I stop lipedema from getting worse?
Lipedema is a long-term condition with no cure, but it can be managed effectively through non-surgical methods. Treatments like wearing compression garments, exercising, and managing weight can help control the symptoms.
What is the life expectancy of a person with lymphedema?
Lymphedema does not directly reduce life expectancy. With early detection and proper care, lymphedema patients can live fulfilling lives. It's important to address misconceptions and focus on self-care.
What are the common complications of lymphedema?
Common complications include skin infections such as cellulitis. Fluid buildup can make the skin more susceptible to germs, and even minor injuries can lead to infections. Infected skin may look swollen, red, and feel warm and painful.
Is cellulite just excess fat?
No, cellulite is more complex than just excess fat. It involves fat, connective tissue, and fluid retention. The dimpled look of cellulite happens when fat pushes against the skin while the connective tissues pull down, creating an uneven surface.
Why do I see more cellulite as I lose weight?
As you lose weight, cellulite may become more noticeable because there's less fat to smooth out the connective tissue, making the dimpling stand out more.